The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

Ger Brennan: ‘You can’t look at a fella now sometimes without getting booked’

The Dublin defender believes GAA chiefs are taking the ‘physicality out of the game’.

Johnny McCaffrey (left) and Ger Brennan (right) at yesterday's launch of the 2013 Dublin Spring Series.
Johnny McCaffrey (left) and Ger Brennan (right) at yesterday's launch of the 2013 Dublin Spring Series.
Image: INPHO/Ryan Byrne

DUBLIN FOOTBALLER GER Brennan believes GAA chiefs are taking the ‘physicality out of the game’ with the constant changes being made to the playing rules.

It was recently announced that referees could have the power to issue black cards next year as part of the GAA’s efforts to clamp down on cynical tactics.

The proposals, published by the GAA’s Football Review Committee, will be voted on in Derry at the association’s annual Congress in March.

Yet Brennan, speaking at yesterday’s launch of the 2013 Spring Series in Croke Park, has questioned the direction the game is going in.

The defender expressed his opinion that Gaelic football is being over-complicated for players and referees while it is starting to resemble a non-contact sport like basketball.

“They’re always trying to change the game around. What’s wrong with it? Didn’t they have a black book a few years ago? That was fine, I thought. Sometimes they try to over-complicate it for the players and for the referees.

“You can’t look at a fella now sometimes without getting booked. I look at the hurlers and they very much tear into each other and they get on with it.

“But Gaelic has gone a bit like basketball at times and how often do you see a fella hit a fella a shoulder and there’s not a free?

“They are taking the physicality out of the game in my opinion. Certainly some of the cynical stuff like time-wasting and lads pulling each other down with rugby tackles needs to be looked at.

“But a lad giving a good shoulder thump what’s wrong with that? Many referees are blowing up for that and they’re giving rash bookings.

“A big hit is a part of the game. I remember a couple of seasons ago Marc Ó Se got a straight red card for a shoulder. I know it was rescinded but referees don’t know how to deal with it because they’re reacting to the crowd and stuff.”

Lilywhite Johnston back starring on the pitch

Saturday night fever for Dublin and Kildare

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (4 Comments)

  • Surely a sin bin would be a better idea to clamp down on deliberate fouling whenever a forward crosses the 21 yard line. Not talking about any team in particular…
    The lack of any real tackle in Gaelic football is probably what’s brought us to this stage sadly. Introduction of an Aussie rules style tackle could help maybe?

    Reply
    • Was the proposed rule change not amended so a black card would mean entering a sin bin for 10 mins, I could be wrong here but I thought that was the case.

      No definition of the tackle is certainly a problem but I don’t think an Aussie rules style tackle is the answer.

      A sin bin for cynical pulling and dragging, blocking off of runs and it should also be used for abusing the ref as this has to be stopped ASAP. I don’t see an issue with a sin bin for any of these. Also over the course of league and championship, accumulation of 3 yellow cards should mean a game ban.

      I do agree with Brennan on the physicality being taken out of the game though. Nothing better than seeing a good, strong, fair shoulder to shoulder tackle, which for some reason is being taken out of the game

      Reply
    • I think the black card proposal is that any player deemed to be cynically fouling by the referee is automatically substituted but only after three black cards is there no substitute brought on to replace him.
      That rule seems very soft on the offending team to me

      Reply
    • That was the original proposal but I had it in my head it was amend.

      If that still is the proposal I think your right that’s its a bit soft and will only give stronger teams a greater advantage due to stronger panels.

      Something needs to be done with the cynical fouling and at least they are trying to take measures to reduce it.

      Reply

Add New Comment