The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 19 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Analysis: Guardiola’s era may have been as good as it gets

As Pep Guardiola leaves Barcelona after a period in which the club dominated football like no other team in the last four decades, Miguel Delaney argues that was down to a perfect football pyramid… best represented and understood by the man at the tip.

This is the end: Guardiola leaves Barcelona... for now
This is the end: Guardiola leaves Barcelona... for now
Image: PA

AT THE VERY high point of Barcelona’s spell of victories over the last four years, Arrigo Sacchi enthused that “like my Milan, this team mark a ‘before’ and ‘after’ in world football”.

After all that, though, we are also now truly “after” Pep Guardiola’s Barca.

In an emotional press conference, the now-former Camp Nou manager claimed that one of the reasons for his resignation was because those four years “felt like an eternity”.

It was an appropriate choice of words. Because the Barcelona team he has provided and presided over was genuinely one for the ages.

Indeed, without any hint of hyperbole, we have witnessed true history over the past four years. In football terms – from the philosophy, to the infrastructure to the eventually exquisite events on the pitch – this may well be as good as it gets.

Consider the major details.

How unprecedented was it, after all, for so many teary players to present at their manager’s departing press conference?

And that evident cohesion was a crucial part of what brought this Barca team close to occasional perfection. But, while the football and the Sergio Busquets-style behaviour may have sometimes dipped – as we admittedly saw in the last 10 days – Guardiola himself represented the tip of what was an undeniably perfect football pyramid.

At the base, we had one of the most renowned, refined and fruitful youth academies in the sport. Above that, then, was a once-in-a-generation nucleus of world-class players in Xavi, Andres Iniesta, Gerard Pique, Carlos Puyol, Sergio Busquets and, above all, Leo Messi who were all produced by that academy.  Presiding over all of that, then, was a manager who had an innate understanding of both how the club worked and how to enhance it.


As well the major defining details like the possession he preached and the pressing he demanded, Guardiola’s smaller, more intricate tactical tweaks ensured Barca played every game on their own terms like no-one else in history. Indeed, no other team – not even Ajax of the ’70s – forced such extreme defensive responses in opposition sides.

Of course, throughout Guardiola’s time, we heard constant repetition of the team’s resounding possession stats. But, until the last week, all of those passes had a point. The extreme numbers were reflected in the points and scoring records Barca have been breaking and setting since 2008. Indeed, perhaps the most startling statistic of all: almost 10% of Guardiola’s total number of defeats here came in the last 10 days.

No, this Barca may not have ultimately retained the European Cup. And that failure to achieve continental football’s gold-standard feat may ensure they are only one of the greats rather than the outright greatest. In many ways, it might even be a wasted opportunity.

But, when you put it into context, it’s worth considering that – just like in their general matches – this Barcelona dominated football more than any other team in the last three decades. Indeed, no side since Liverpool of the early ’80s got so far, so often in so many competitions.

Not even Arrigo Sacchi’s Milan.

Over four seasons, that team only (an admittedly relative term) won two European Cups and a solitary Serie A. Either side of those victories, meanwhile, they got eliminated from the 1987-88 Uefa Cup in the second round and the 1990-91 champions’ competition in the quarter-finals.

By contrast, across the same spell of time, Barca have won two Champions Leagues, three titles, one Copa Del Rey and reached another two finals of the latter competition as well as two further continental semi-finals.

But, of course, this team often transcended simple facts. They may not have matched the Champions League’s greatest achievements but, when it came to the fundamental quality of their football, it was arguably unparalleled when it was at its very best. Even more impressively, they often saved their best for the very biggest occasions – the 6-2 and 5-0 Clasico wins over Real Madrid, the two victories Champions League finals against Manchester United.

Ultimately, though, the sheer intensity of all of that – as well as the extreme pressure to make it even more exceptional – got to Guardiola.

“I don’t have any energy left,” he wearily explained this morning. “I need to recharge.”

Because, of course, while Guardiola may prove the best possible coach the club will ever have, it’s only worth keeping him if he can continue to give his absolute best. And that no longer seemed to be the case. As he said himself, “it would have been a bad idea to go on”.

In the end, though, Guardiola had one last surprising tactical side-step: he was king-maker in former assistant Tito Vilanova’s appointment.

Many in Barcelona are already talking about how he will be Guardiola’s Joe Fagan, how the club are creating their own Boot Room.

In that, it’s also worth mentioning, that his own resignation puts a different spin on the ludicrously long careers of two other English-based managers: Alex Ferguson and Arsene Wenger. As the Arsenal manager once said “you need strength, animal strength to stay in this job.”

But, like both Ferguson and Wenger, perhaps Guardiola’s greatest achievement goes beyond mere management. He has irrevocably altered the history and future of the club.

Before he took over, even though many of the main details – like the youth system – were in place, Barca still hadn’t completely overcome their own past as mere moral victors. Even the 2006 Champions League win was followed by immediate implosion. There was deflation and depression, after all, in the summer when Guardiola took over.

That isn’t quite the case now, in the summer he leaves.

Yes, there is evident sadness around the club. But also a clear sense of mission. Of upholding a new winning legacy.

As Sandro Rosell said, “Guardiola has put the club in good stead… we need to manage his heritage as best as possible.”

And that’s perhaps the greatest testament. For a man whose teams always played on their own terms, he has left on his own too.

In Barcelona, that is rare.  Almost as rare as the quality of the football.

LIVE: Pep Guardiola’s Camp Nou announcement

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (20 Comments)

  • He will go down as the best manager of the modern game,I don’t think football can get anymore better the way he had barca playing

    Reply
  • pjryan 27/04/12 #

    One of the greats , he did have some of the best footballers at his disposal , xavi, iniesta and player of the year for the last three seasons messi. There was an inevitability about his departure , four seasons at the top winning all there was to win huge pressure. No team stays at the top forever . It would be interesting to see how he measures up managing in Italy or england like mourinho has done .

    Reply
  • Barcelona are now a machine. Listening to liam brady on tv one night saying that he was abroad watching the barcelona U14′s in a youth competition playing exact same way as seniors and that they too were also phenomenal. He summary was barcelona are not going to go away any time soon.
    Pep did not create this style of play. He was apart of it. It was a long journey for barca, a system started in the early 90′s to reach its fruition after around 12-14 years. The last few years they are perfecting it. Barcelona are changing football. As for their new manager being a gamble, so was pep when he was selected.

    Reply
  • Forget Pep Miguel Delaney is on his way to similar heights in sports journalism …..brilliant article superbly written and it was a joy to read

    Reply
  • Good to see Miguel still writing with well informed opinion .. Miss the “turbine” sports section..

    Reply
  • It’ll be interesting to see where he ends up. Arsenal or Liverpool would make the most sense for me. Rodolfo Borrell is already at Liverpool too, given the talk about Txixi Bergestain possibly going there it could defintely happen.

    Reply
  • Excellent, excellent article Miguel.

    Reply
  • couldn’t agree more…. one of the best articles i have read in a long time…. and the best on this particular subject…. keep up the good work

    Reply
  • Olu 27/04/12 #

    Enjoying their plaing style is subjective. I found them boring to watch for 90 minutes bar the odd Messi magic. At the end of the day, Crujiff is still Barcelona’s most important personal in modern football.

    Reply
    • I had this argument with someone after Spain won the World Cup, in that they’re boring to watch. Its really not their fault other teams aren’t up to taking them on. If other teams were better, their games wouldn’t look like a training match.

      Reply
    • Yep. Completely agree Val. In many ways, Spain and Barca have been victims of their own success. An aura has been created around them which means opposition teams defend more deeply against them than against any other team. It’s a lot harder to be exciting when you have 10 men massed around a box. If teams came out and played,we’d see how exciting both were.
      Look, for example, at how exhilarating Spain were against Russia in the opening game of Euro 2008. Russia didn’t defend deep so got torn apart with thrilling moves in the break.

      Reply
  • jrbmc 27/04/12 #

    I wouldn’t say a major force in the last ten decades !!!!! Certainly in the last 4 yrs but outside if that they have been a bit of a up and down club

    Reply
    • Didn’t say that. The point is they’ve dominated their era like no-one else in four decades. In four years, they’ve won two Champions Leagues, reached another two semi-finals, won three titles, won one cup and reached another two finals. No team since Liverpool 1975-84 has got so far, so often in so many competitions.

      Reply
  • Wouldn’t blame him after going two rounds with the mighty Chelsea anyone would be exhausted and needing a break.

    He will come back fit and ready to Manage the blues this summer.

    Reply

Add New Comment